The Power of Partnership

The Power of Partnership

RENEW Wisconsin and Alliant Energy have agreed to preserve net metering for two years and have created a clear pathway for future rooftop solar installations. At the end of the two-year period, new Alliant solar customers will shift away from net metering and into Power Partnership, a proposal that will support the sustainability of the solar industry.

Power Partnership preserves key aspects of net metering while creating new benefits. The agreement is a compromise that offers a durable framework that recognizes the value of each customer’s solar installation to Alliant’s infrastructure. Power Partnership limits the risk to installers, ensures a steady revenue stream to solar customers, and provides a solid growth path for solar and storage.

Additionally, after net metering is fully phased out, Power Partnership will continue to provide customers and installers with the information they need to estimate payback periods for new installations. This was a non-negotiable aspect of RENEW’s agreement with Alliant.

This is a win for the solar industry and wouldn’t be possible without the incredible grassroots efforts of every person and organization who submitted public comments and testimony to the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin. This unified action helped bring Alliant to the table.

These collective efforts gave us the opportunity to bargain from a strong position and have a voice in crafting what a net metering transition in Wisconsin looks like. This agreement creates certainty for the solar industry and the customers who support it, in both the short and long term.

Key Aspects of the Proposal:

  • New customers with installations under 20 kW will be able to choose between net metering and Power Partnership until Dec. 31, 2025.
  • Net metering customers will receive legacy treatment until 2032.
  • Bill credits earned under Power Partnership will carry over on a monthly basis for one year.
  • Power Partnership will expand access to installations between 20 kW and 75 kW.
  • Alliant will create a payback calculator to help customers plan financially for their solar installations.
  • Customers will have a minimum charge of $10 per month for installations up to 20 kW and $15 per month for installations between 20-75 kW. This charge will not apply to current net metering customers.

Transitions away from net metering are rarely this favorable to solar customers, and we are grateful for Alliant’s collaboration and the organized support of clean energy advocates. RENEW still believes that net metering is the best policy for Wisconsin’s current solar industry, and our opposition to MGE’s proposal continues. We hope that we can depend on your support in that effort.

Clean Energy Legislative Update • September 2023

Clean Energy Legislative Update • September 2023

The 2023-24 legislative session in Wisconsin is nearing the halfway point. Much has happened in the last year, and we are hoping to make great strides by the end of the current legislative session.

This year’s biennial budget bill for 2023-25 had several provisions we were monitoring — however, most of them were removed from the final version. The budget did ultimately include a $75 increase to annual registration fees for electric vehicles.

Despite the outcome of the budget bill, there are still opportunities in several key areas. One of our main focuses of late has been net metering and the two rate cases before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW). We are also working to remove barriers in the effort to build EV charging infrastructure while also supporting bills that would allow Wisconsin residents to participate in community solar projects.

Net Metering Proposal

In most states, when you generate electricity from solar panels on your property, you get a credit for the energy you produce, reducing your electricity purchases from the utility and some compensation for sending any excess electricity from your system back to the grid. RENEW Wisconsin has been active in two net metering rate cases before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW).

In the Alliant Energy rate case, RENEW and Alliant have agreed to preserve net metering for two years and have created a clear pathway for future rooftop solar installations. At the end of the two-year period, new Alliant solar customers will shift away from net metering and into Power Partnership, a proposal that will support the sustainability of the solar industry.

RENEW still believes that net metering is the best policy for Wisconsin’s current solar industry, and our opposition to MGE’s proposal continues. The comment period for MGE’s rate case before the PSCW has closed. A final decision from the PSCW in both the MGE and Alliant rate cases is expected in late October or early November.

  • RENEW staff has testified in both rate cases before the PSCW.
  • RENEW has encouraged and empowered our members and the public to support net metering through the public comments process.
  • RENEW staff is engaged with state legislators, making them aware of how these rate cases will affect their constituents and the solar industry in general.

Electric Vehicle Charging

Recognizing the need for better access to charging stations to support the electric vehicle industry, RENEW is working to support efforts to remove some of the barriers created by restrictions in state law. State law limits private companies’ ability to build charging stations by only allowing electric utilities to sell electricity to the public.

  • RENEW anticipates legislation (likely led by Sen. Howard Marklein) to be introduced this fall to remove some of these barriers.
  • RENEW is seeking a proposal that would allow non-utilities to provide electricity at charging stations by using the national standard of charging by the kilowatt hour rather than by the time it takes to charge.
  • RENEW staff have been in regular communication with various interested parties and we hope to see movement on this proposal soon.
  • To support these efforts, we also have preliminary plans to host educational, lobbying, and test-driving electric vehicle events through the fall.

Community Solar

Current Wisconsin state law limits solar installations to larger utility-built projects and smaller rooftop installations on private property of individual homes or businesses. What is lacking is the option for community-based projects for individuals to participate in solar energy generation even if they do not own the building or have adequate sun exposure or roof space to accommodate solar installations.

RENEW Wisconsin has joined a coalition of groups that support community solar projects that would provide new opportunities for the industry and customers. Two bills were introduced earlier this year that would allow Wisconsin residents to participate in community solar projects. SB 226 was authored by Sen. Duey Stroebel, and AB 258 was authored by Rep. Scott Krug.

  • RENEW is encouraging the chairman of the committee, Sen. Julian Bradley, to schedule a hearing in October in the Senate Committee on Utilities & Technology.
  • More than 30 organizations are listed as lobbyists on the proposal, with an almost equal number for and against.
  • Utility groups and labor representatives have strongly opposed the bills.
  • Supporters along with RENEW include the Alliance of WI Retailers, NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Association, League of WI Municipalities, WI Property Taxpayer Association, and Fieldworks Power.

 

Elk Creek Solar Project Approved!

Elk Creek Solar Project Approved!

The Elk Creek Solar project, located in the Township of Spring Brook in Dunn County, was approved this month by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW). The 300-megawatt (MW) solar project is paired with a 76.6 MW battery energy storage system and is expected to go online by the spring of 2026.

As designed, Elk Creek Solar would supply homegrown, affordable, emission-free electricity to power the equivalent of approximately 60,000 homes for at least 30 years. RENEW Wisconsin submitted testimony in support of the project, and we are excited for construction to begin.

The developer of the project, TED Renewables, has been engaged and transparent with the Springbrook community throughout the approval process by providing detailed information on the benefits and timeline of the project. Beyond generating revenue for local schools and government services, the project is expected to create upwards of 650 jobs during the construction phase and 3-4 highly skilled long-term jobs.

According to TED Renewables, the annual tax revenues for all taxing districts will exceed $1.2 million. As stated in the La Crosse Tribune, “Spring Brook township of $500,000, Dunn County of $700,000 and the Elk Mound Area School District of $60,000.”

Construction is projected to start in the fall of 2024. Throughout the life of the project, the landowner will retain the title to the land and sign a 30-year lease, with the option for a five-year extension. At the end of its operational life, the equipment will be recycled or reused, and the land will be restored. By giving the soil time to rest and planting deep-rooted plants, the quality of the soil will be improved substantially by the time it is once again ready for agricultural use.

Elk Creek Solar is the 17th project larger than 100 MW the PSCW has approved since 2019, totaling 3,249 MW for Wisconsin. Several other projects, including Silver Maple Solar, are awaiting approval.

Protect Rooftop Solar in Wisconsin

Protect Rooftop Solar in Wisconsin

Net metering is a utility billing policy that enables customers who generate electricity from their own solar systems to receive a bill credit for any energy they export to the grid. This arrangement encourages residential and business customers to invest in solar power, reducing carbon emissions and providing substantial economic benefits to their neighbors and communities.

According to Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA), “traditional net energy metering (NEM) is fundamentally a bill credit that represents the full retail value of distributed electricity delivered to the distribution system, and has been a critical policy for valuing and enabling distributed generation.”

If passed, this utility proposal will depress demand for rooftop solar, leading to layoffs for local clean energy workers, creating new hardships for customers and local governments in meeting their clean energy goals, and moving solar out of reach for many Wisconsinites.

We’ve included sample messages for you to submit comments to the PSCW. The PSCW allows one comment per case. As you prepare your comments, keep in mind that customizing your message will have a greater impact. Comments are the most effective when they are short, to the point, and have a personal perspective. Please take the time to share why net metering is important to you! MGE’s comment period is open through September 26.

Sample Message –    MGE:

I’m writing in support of fair net metering policies for Wisconsin. The changes to net metering under review in Docket No. 3270-UR-125 would make investing in rooftop solar harder and more expensive.

Net metering empowers Wisconsinites to take control of their energy consumption, reduce their carbon footprint, and contribute to a cleaner, more sustainable future. It is the single most important policy enabling every Wisconsin home, farm, business, and institution to own solar. By reducing strain on the grid, stabilizing energy prices, and fostering job growth, the benefits of net metering extend well beyond the solar customer.

Madison Gas and Electric’s proposal before the Public Service Commission will unfairly reduce the compensation customers receive for the energy they produce with their investment in solar. In addition, the compensation rates will be subject to change every year, creating uncertainty over the system’s value in the long term. Advancing this proposal will make it more difficult for people who cannot afford the upfront cost of purchasing solar panels to find the financing they might need, and will discourage the adoption of rooftop solar, negatively impacting our local economy.

Rooftop solar can be a boon for historically marginalized communities, providing access to clean energy and reducing utility bills for households disproportionately burdened by high electricity costs. These savings free up resources for other essentials like education, healthcare, and better living conditions. Our energy policies should be making it easier for all Wisconsinites to reap the benefits of clean energy.

Now is not the time to derail our progress on distributed solar in Wisconsin!

Thank you for your support on this important issue.

Questions?

Please send them to Executive Director, Sam Dunaiski, at sam@renewwisconsin.org.

 

Electric Vehicles (EVs) — The Magic Trick That Became a Real Solution to Very Real Problems

Electric Vehicles (EVs) — The Magic Trick That Became a Real Solution to Very Real Problems

Co-authored by Julia Herkert

In 1830s Scotland, an inventor named Robert Anderson dedicated himself to a parlor trick: a horseless carriage. By connecting a battery to a carriage, Anderson astounded the public with his vehicle that could mysteriously move on its own. While this carriage ran on a non-rechargeable battery that could hardly travel a few miles before running out of power, Anderson’s prototype triggered a breakthrough that would last centuries. Today, electric vehicles (EVs) have evolved into a leading force in the push toward a healthier and more sustainable way to transport people and goods, and it all started with a magic trick.

Hopefully, at this point, we don’t have to convince anyone that air pollution is harmful. But for those that prefer data over opinions, we recommend taking a look at a recent study by the University of Wisconsin–Madison suggesting that eliminating air pollution emissions from energy-related activities in the United States would prevent more than 50,000 premature deaths and provide more than $600 billion in benefits each year from avoided illness and death.

RENEW promotes EVs for the same reasons we encourage clean energy – replacing gasoline and diesel vehicles with EVs can help reduce air pollution and produce a healthier, more vibrant Wisconsin for all. Like clean energy deployment, putting EVs on the road requires strategic technology, policy, and infrastructure coordination. This coordination is essential because the technology alone isn’t enough to produce enduring results. Let’s look at the history of EV technology in America and the policies and infrastructure we need to unlock the benefits of an electrified – pollution-free – transportation future.

EVs have been around for decades, and many waves of innovation have occurred since Anderson’s horseless carriage prototype. The most recent wave of vehicle electrification in the U.S. started with General Motors’ EV1. The EV1 was considered the first mass-market electric vehicle and utilized lead batteries for a range of about 100 miles. “It was an exciting time because the technology of an electric vehicle was obvious,” stated Annette Clayton, a former executive at General Motors, “The question was, could you make money doing it… and if the cars were available, would you start to see the infrastructure to actually charge those vehicles become available?” You can watch the 2006 documentary Who Killed the Electric Car? to learn more about General Motors’ EV1 program.

Unfortunately, while demand for the EV1 was high and the car was road ready, the infrastructure wasn’t prepared for the EV1. A pattern of electric transportation technology advancing beyond available infrastructure and policy has long plagued EVs’ stable integration into everyday transportation modes. Not only this, but General Motors was not making a substantial profit from the mass production of these vehicles despite there being a high demand for them. With little to no charging infrastructure to reduce range anxiety (the fear that an electric vehicle will not have enough battery charge to reach its destination, leaving its occupants stranded) and little room for profit, General Motors bought back their EV1s and killed the electric car. Two decades later, EV technology is unquestionably ready, and several automakers are swearing to go all-EV by 2040 or sooner.

Only one percent of the 250 million cars, SUVs, and light-duty trucks on American roads are electric, but the industry projects that 25 to 30 percent of new car sales could be electric by 2030. Moreover, electric vehicle prices continue to decrease while vehicle range (the distance an EV can travel on a single charge) continues to increase. Refueling times are getting shorter, too, with some EV models capable of recharging their batteries to 80 percent in less than 18 minutes.

Now that EV technology is ready, The Federal, State, and local governments are investing in developing the necessary infrastructure. Specifically, the U.S Government plans to build a network of 500,000 EV charging stations along the main highway corridors by 2030. The National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure Plan, or NEVI, provides funding to build EV charging stations within a mile of the main highway corridors at least every fifty miles. Wisconsin is planning to use $78.6 Million from the NEVI plan to build 62 EV charging hubs along I-90, I-94, I-39, I-41, I-43, and other highways. Check this blog post to learn more about Wisconsin’s Electric Vehicle Infrastructure (WEVI) plan.

So, what about EV policy? And why do we need policies to deploy EVs? EVs use electricity rather than petroleum fuels, and because electricity markets are heavily regulated, many aspects of EV deployment are controlled by energy regulation. For example, in Wisconsin, only public utilities are allowed to sell electricity. In other words, EV charging stations operating in Wisconsin are not allowed to charge EV drivers by the amount of electricity that goes into their EV batteries or kilowatt-hours used. Instead, EV charging stations in Wisconsin charge a parking fee as a proxy for EV charging. On our last visit to an Electrify America fast charging station, we paid $4.32 for 27 minutes of charge, billed at $0.16 per minute. These time-based rates create inequities with fast charging because EVs have different charging speeds. Put, EV drivers of slower-charging EVs pay more for electricity at public charging stations in Wisconsin than those who drive faster-charging vehicles. An example to illustrate this is that the Porsche Taycan can take up to 270 kW of power, while the Chevrolet Bolt can only handle up to 50 kW. This means that Porsche drivers pay significantly less than Chevrolet drivers when using fast charging stations that provide over 50 kW, which is unfair. The NEVI plan requires energy-based billing at all EV charging stations built with federal funding to address this issue. Unfortunately, Wisconsin is among the few states prohibiting energy-based EV charging fees. The NEVI plan also requires a minimum charging speed of 150 kW at all charging stations.

But not all EV policies are about electricity. Many EV policies address the affordability of EVs and access to home charging. For example, Vermont passed a law to help the highest-need drivers switch to EVs and save on fuel costs. The state of Illinois is creating legislation to make it easier for multifamily dwellers to access home EV charging. Other EV policies include topics related to road funding (gas tax), direct sales of EVs, and emissions standards.

The moment has finally arrived where infrastructure and policies are catching up to the advanced technologies of EVs, and these cleaner vehicles are now rightfully taking center stage in the movement toward a more sustainable future. Through technological innovation, infrastructure development, and smart policymaking, EVs provide solutions to many problems ranging from air pollution to energy security. Next time you are in the market for a new or used vehicle, you should test drive an EV. You won’t regret it!

Trees, Ownership, or Finances Blocking Access to Solar Energy? No Problem with Community Solar- A Guest Blog

Trees, Ownership, or Finances Blocking Access to Solar Energy? No Problem with Community Solar- A Guest Blog

From the Summer 2023 Hornblower newsletter, published by the Dudgeon Monroe Neighborhood Association.

Community solar is on a steep incline locally, regionally, and nationally. By the end of 2022 there were over 2,000 community solar projects distributed across 40 states, including Wisconsin.

Community solar allows individuals to support or own part of a solar system with others in their community. The supported solar system is typically located close to your county, has good solar access, and can take advantage of economies of scale and professional management.

Many households do not have the ability to adopt solar energy at their residence due to shade, are not owners, or don’t have the finances to purchase a solar system. The Dudgeon Monroe neighborhood has a lot of trees, which is fantastic for many reasons: shade, beauty, oxygen, wind barriers, and noise reduction, to name a few. However, large trees, especially on the south side, reduce the energy and economic ability to make electricity from the sun on your home or business. 

Community solar allows almost everyone to support adoption of solar energy wherever they live or whatever their financial situation. The three current options for Dudgeon Monroe residents include: joining MGE’s Shared Solar Program, investing in the SolarShareWI Co-op created by RENEW Wisconsin, or Legacy Solar’s Co-op. 

There are many ways to support solar in our neighborhood besides placing panels on a home or business. It’s a way to earn a modest return on extra cash while doing your part to support a clean energy future.

MGE’s Shared Solar program offers households and small businesses the opportunity to reserve a share of the electricity produced by MGE’s solar arrays in Middleton serving the program.

SolarShare WI Co-op allows co-op members to invest in 1-5 megawatt solar projects in Wisconsin and get a projected return on their investment of 5%.

Legacy Solar Co-op allows members to buy bonds or be a “Tax Sponsor” in systems typically on nonprofit commercial applications like churches, schools, and similar buildings.

Don Wichert, May 2023
Founder of RENEW Wisconsin and Emeritus board member.